Right to try, right to buy, right to test – Washington Post
By daniellenierenberg
By Sally Satel By Sally Satel February 21 at 8:04 PM
(Dr. Sally Satel, who has guest-blogged here before, was kind enough to write up this item on a topic that has long interested me; Im delighted to pass it along: -EV)
In 2007, Eugene Volokh, the host of this site, published an essay in the Harvard Law Reviewtitled Medical Self-Defense, Prohibited Experimental Therapies, and Payment for Organs in which he argued that the government should need a very good reason to prevent sick people from saving their own lives.
That insight impels the Right to Try movement, which seeks to give terminally ill patients the right to try drugs that show promise but not have received FDA approval and which has received sympathetic hearings from President Trump and Vice President Pence. One of the leaders of Right to Try reform, the libertarian Goldwater Institute, said it best: We just fundamentally do not believe that you should have to apply to the government for permission to try to save your own life.
That principle has vital implications for patients needing bone marrow and kidney transplants.
Each year, 2,000 to 3,000 individuals with leukemia and other forms of bone marrow disease die while waiting to receive another persons bone marrow cells. Its not that strangers are indifferent to their plight, but that suitable biological matches are hard to find. And even when a match is found, there is a 1-in-2 chance that the needle-in-a-haystack donor either cant be located by registry personnel or, incomprehensibly, refuses to donate even though he had earlier volunteered to be tested.
We can enlarge the pool of potential donors while increasing the likelihood that compatible donors will follow through if they are paid or if sick patients (or charities acting on their behalf) have the Right to Buy, as I call it.
But there is an obstacle to buying. The 1984 National Organ Transplant Act, or NOTA, bans exchange of valuable consideration that is, anything of material worth for solid organs, such as kidneys and livers, as well as for bone marrow.
The Institute for Justice, a libertarian public-interest law firm, fought the prohibition. It sued the Justice Department on behalf of families afraid their ill loved ones would die because they couldnt get a bone marrow transplant.
In a unanimous 2012 ruling, a three-judge panel of the U.S. Court of Appeals for the 9th Circuit rejected the federal governments argument that obtaining bone-marrow stem cells through a needle in a donors arm violates NOTA. The judges based their decision on the fact that modern bone-marrow procurement, a process known as apheresis, is akin to drawing blood. Indeed, filtered stem cells, they held, are merely components of blood, no different from blood-derived plasma, platelets and clotting factors, all of which are replenished by the body within weeks of a donation. Because its legal to compensate blood donors, its also legal to pay bone marrow donors, the court ruled.
Unfortunately, the Department of Health and Human Services rejected the courts ruling. In 2013, it proposed a rule that would extend the NOTA prohibition to bone marrow stem cells. Under the proposed regulation, anyone who accepted material gain for giving bone-marrow stem cells would be subject to NOTAs penalties, facing imprisonment for up to five years. According to HHS, compensation runs afoul of NOTAs intent to ban commodification of human stem cells and to curb opportunities for coercion and exploitation, encourage altruistic donation and decrease the likelihood of disease transmission.
The solicitor general could have asked the Supreme Court to review the 9th Circuits bone-marrow decision, but he declined. Perhaps he grasped the central folly of HHSs position: How could the agency justify its worry about opportunities for coercion and exploitation and the likelihood of disease transmission when it came to bone marrow cells, yet not apply those same concerns to plasma?
For three years, HHS has been silent on its proposed rule. Meanwhile, people are dying because nonprofits that want to begin paying donors on behalf of needy patients cant move forward until they are assured that the agency cant shut them down. The Institute for Justice is considering a legal challenge over the HHS delay, which is causing needless deaths.
But perhaps the lawsuit can wait. With a new administration that is skeptical of overregulation, HHS Secretary Tom Price could withdraw the proposed rule. Ideally, Congress would thwart future regulatory blockades by amending NOTA to stipulate that marrow stem cells are not organs covered by the act.
Changes to NOTA should also be made for other organs. I feel strongly about this on fundamental grounds of liberty but also because, in 2005, I needed to save my own life. I developed kidney failure but could not find a donor. Thank goodness, an angel, or as some readers know her, Virginia Postrel, heard about my predicament and gave me a kidney. And this summer another living saint, Kimberly Hendrickson, who saw how desperate I was many years ago, offered me one of hers when the first transplant began to fail. Every day, 12 people die because no one wasable to come to their rescue and, had a patient offered money for an organ, both the patient and the donor who accepted the money would face felony charges.
Congress could take the bold step of revising NOTA to permit donors who are willing to save the life of a stranger through kidney donation to receive valuable consideration from governments or nonprofit organizations. Or, lawmakers could take the intermediate step of creating a pilot program allowing doctors to study the effect of such measures, as proposed last May by Rep. Matthew Cartwright (D-Pa.), who introduced the Organ Donor Clarification Act of 2016.
Rather than large sums of cash, potential rewards could include a contribution to the donors retirement fund, an income tax credit or a tuition voucher, lifetime health insurance, a contribution to a charity of the donors choice, or loan forgiveness. Only the government, or a government-designated charity, would be allowed to disburse the rewards. Consequently, all patients, not just those with financial means, could benefit. The funds could potentially come from the savings from stopping dialysis, which costs roughly $80,000 a year per person.
The pilot programs, to be designed by individual medical centers, could also impose a waiting period on prospective donors, thereby cooling any impulsivity. Prospective donors would be fully informed about the risks of surgery and carefully screened for physical and emotional health, as all non-compensated kidney donors are now.
The idea of the government standing between a dying person and his salvation is deeply troubling. I know. We need to at least test better ways to recruit more marrow and kidney donors.
Dr. Sally Satelis a resident scholar at the American Enterprise Institute and editor ofWhen Altruism isnt Enough: The Case for Compensating Kidney Donors.
Continued here:
Right to try, right to buy, right to test - Washington Post
- 5 year old boy from Iraq undergoes world's first of its kind bone marrow transplantation in India - The Times of India - March 31st, 2025
- Superior outcomes of haploidentical hematopoietic cell transplantation over chemotherapy in AML patients 55 years or older - Nature.com - March 31st, 2025
- Blood and Marrow Transplantation and Cellular Therapy Center - NYU Langone Health - March 22nd, 2025
- Bone Marrow Transplantation Market Poised to Achieve USD 14,336 Billion by 2031 - Persistence Market Research - openPR - March 22nd, 2025
- BioRestorative Therapies to Report 2024 Financial Results and Host Conference Call on March 27, 2025 - The Manila Times - March 22nd, 2025
- Man Cured Of Sickle Cell Disease In New York Thanks To New Gene Therapy - Forbes - March 22nd, 2025
- Boost in cancer treatment: PGI working on lab for stem cell, gene therapies - The Times of India - March 22nd, 2025
- Clonal dynamics and somatic evolution of haematopoiesis in mouse - Nature.com - March 11th, 2025
- Mitochondria-enriched hematopoietic stem cells exhibit elevated self-renewal capabilities, thriving within the context of aged bone marrow -... - March 11th, 2025
- TET2 deficiency increases the competitive advantage of hematopoietic stem and progenitor cells through upregulation of thrombopoietin receptor... - March 11th, 2025
- Garuda Therapeutics Closes $50 Million Series A-1 Financing to Advance Off-the-Shelf Blood Stem Cell Therapies - GlobeNewswire - March 11th, 2025
- Abu Dhabi Stem Cells Center and Yas Clinic first in UAE to receive AABB accreditation for haematopoietic progenitor cell collection - Abu Dhabi Media... - March 11th, 2025
- Discovery of lung-based blood stem cells may transform transplant therapies - Medical Xpress - March 1st, 2025
- VUMC part of new study validating curative therapy for sickle cell disease - VUMC Reporter - March 1st, 2025
- What Is the Role of MRD Testing Before HSCT in MDS/MPN? - DocWire News - March 1st, 2025
- Melphalan-based conditioning with post-transplant cyclophosphamide for peripheral blood stem cell transplantation: donor effect - Nature.com - March 1st, 2025
- Mesenchymal Stem Cells Market Projected to Reach USD 11.26 Billion by 2034, Growing at a CAGR of 12.9% - openPR - March 1st, 2025
- See snazzy slugs in all their luminous glory Februarys best science images - Nature.com - March 1st, 2025
- On the origin of neutrophils - Nature.com - March 1st, 2025
- Four-year-old donates stem cells to save her baby sister from blood cancer in Odisha - The Hindu - February 20th, 2025
- Effect of pre-transplant cytoreductive therapy on the outcomes of patients with MDS or secondary AML evolving from MDS undergoing allo-HSCT: a... - February 20th, 2025
- A heart disease trigger that lurks inside bone marrow - Harvard Health - February 20th, 2025
- 4-year-old donates stem cells to save sister as SCB performs first-of-a-kind bone marrow transplant in Odisha - OTV News - February 20th, 2025
- KU Cancer Center recognized for transplant that saved 1-year-olds life - WDAF FOX4 Kansas City - February 20th, 2025
- Orca-T With RIC Is Safe in Advanced Hematologic Malignancies - OncLive - February 20th, 2025
- SCB conducts Odisha's first bone marrow transplant on two-year-old - The New Indian Express - February 20th, 2025
- Bahrain's pioneering use of sickle cell disease treatment hailed by medical experts - The National - February 20th, 2025
- Cancer survivor is the first monumental bone marrow transplant patient in Baton Rouge in 8 years - NOLA.com - February 11th, 2025
- Autologous Cell Therapy Market to Hit Valuation of US$ 44.55 Billion By 2033 | Astute Analytica - GlobeNewswire - February 11th, 2025
- Nanoparticle that cuts middlemen could improve stem cell therapy - Futurity: Research News - January 31st, 2025
- GATA2 mutated allele specific expression is associated with a hyporesponsive state of HSC in GATA2 deficiency syndrome - Nature.com - January 31st, 2025
- Coordinated immune networks in leukemia bone marrow microenvironments distinguish response to cellular therapy - Science - January 31st, 2025
- How the bone marrow microbiome responds to immunotherapy - Chemical & Engineering News - January 31st, 2025
- My Experience With Stem Cell Therapy: Snake Oil or Silver Bullet? - GearJunkie - January 31st, 2025
- Hematopoietic Stem Cell Transplantation - StatPearls - NCBI ... - January 22nd, 2025
- Doctors retrieve stem cells from 20-month-old to treat thalassaemic sister - The Times of India - January 22nd, 2025
- YolTech Therapeutics to Initiate a Clinical Trial for YOLT-204, a First-in-Class Bone Marrow-Targeted In Vivo Gene Editing Therapy for -Thalassemia -... - January 22nd, 2025
- School of Medicine professor receives grant to study improved cancer treatments - Mercer University - January 14th, 2025
- 1st stem cell therapy, new HIV drug approved - ecns - January 5th, 2025
- Suppression of thrombospondin-1mediated inflammaging prolongs hematopoietic health span - Science - January 5th, 2025
- A pilot raced through the airport to surprise an old friend: the woman who saved his life - CNN - December 27th, 2024
- Types of Stem Cell and Bone Marrow Transplants - December 27th, 2024
- Explained: What is mesenchymal stem cell therapy? - Drug Discovery News - December 18th, 2024
- Stem Cell Transplants Offer New Hope for Saving the Worlds Corals - Technology Networks - December 18th, 2024
- Scientists Present Research on Novel Cancer Therapies at ASH - City of Hope - December 18th, 2024
- Navigating CAR-T cell therapy long-term complications - Nature.com - December 18th, 2024
- High-dose chemotherapy followed by autologous stem cell transplant ineffective for patients with mantle cell lymphoma - News-Medical.Net - December 18th, 2024
- Stem Cell Therapy Market Is Expected To Reach Revenue Of - GlobeNewswire - December 18th, 2024
- The Importance of Cellular Therapy in the Clinical Case of a Young Man With a Challenging Precursor B-cell Lymphoblastic Leukemia - Cureus - December 18th, 2024
- A search for the perfect match, Apex six year old in need of donor - CBS17.com - December 18th, 2024
- New insights into survival of breast cancer cells in the bone marrow - News-Medical.Net - December 9th, 2024
- Cellular trafficking and fate mapping of cells within the nervous system after in utero hematopoietic cell transplantation - Nature.com - December 9th, 2024
- Saving lives, one stem cell at a time - Texas A&M The Battalion - December 9th, 2024
- Turn Biotechnologies Announces Landmark Study to Assess Effectiveness of ERA Therapy in Restoring Bone Marrow - PR Newswire UK - December 9th, 2024
- Orca Bio Presents Three-Year Survival Data with Orca-T in Patients with Hematological Malignancies at the 66th ASH Annual Meeting - Yahoo Finance - December 9th, 2024
- You are the match. How UNC student honored her late grandfather with life-saving effort - Raleigh News & Observer - November 29th, 2024
- scRNA-seq revealed transcriptional signatures of human umbilical cord primitive stem cells and their germ lineage origin regulated by imprinted genes... - November 29th, 2024
- Atlanta pilot with an aggressive cancer finds lifesaving help from a stranger and a simple test - The Atlanta Journal Constitution - November 29th, 2024
- Researchers have brought the promise of stem cell therapies closer to reality - The Week - November 29th, 2024
- Bone Marrow Donors Can Be Hard to Find. One Company Is Turning to ... - November 15th, 2024
- Hematopoietic Stem Cells and Their Niche in Bone Marrow - November 15th, 2024
- Bone Marrow Transplant Program - Overview - Mayo Clinic - November 15th, 2024
- Bone Marrow Donors Can Be Hard to Find. One Company Is Turning to Cadavers - WIRED - November 15th, 2024
- More stem cells for sickle cell gene therapy readied with motixafortide - Sickle Cell Disease News - November 15th, 2024
- Skull bone marrow expands throughout life and remains healthy during aging, researchers discover - Medical Xpress - November 15th, 2024
- Adult skull bone marrow is an expanding and resilient haematopoietic reservoir - Nature.com - November 15th, 2024
- Evaluation of standard fludarabine dosing and corresponding exposures in infants and young children undergoing hematopoietic cell transplantation -... - November 15th, 2024
- Stem cells grown in space show super powers but theres a catch - Study Finds - November 15th, 2024
- Getting a Stem Cell or Bone Marrow Transplant - October 21st, 2024
- Acquisition of durable insulin-producing cells from human adipose tissue-derived mesenchymal stem cells as a foundation for cell- based therapy of... - October 21st, 2024
- 1.5 Lakh Indians Register To Save Lives: Join the Mission To Fight Blood Cancer - The Better India - October 21st, 2024
- How Stem Cell and Bone Marrow Transplants Are Used to Treat Cancer - October 13th, 2024
- Stem Cell (Bone Marrow) Transplants - MD Anderson Cancer Center - October 13th, 2024
- Donating Bone Marrow and Stem Cells: The Process and What To Expect - October 13th, 2024
- What to expect as a stem cell or bone marrow donor - October 13th, 2024
- Structural organization of the bone marrow and its role in ... - October 13th, 2024
- Stem cell donor from down the road saved my life after global search - BBC.com - September 23rd, 2024
- Awaiting the call: family hopes to find blood stem cell donor - Claremont Courier - September 23rd, 2024
- Michigan woman one of first in world to successfully receive bone marrow from deceased donor - WDIV ClickOnDetroit - September 23rd, 2024
- Next-generation stem cell transplant: Revolutionizing a lifesaving cancer therapy - The Business Journals - September 23rd, 2024
